I grew up Southern Baptist. Where I grew up it wasn’t necessary to say “Southern” – it was just Baptist. I have friends who were traumatized by the church, but that is not my story at all. I loved growing up in the church. We were a “twice on Sunday/ once on Wednesday night/every night during revivals” family – well, at least my mom, my sister, and I were. Dad was more of a “Mother’s Day and Easter” guy.
I sang in the youth choir. I attended, and then led, Sunday School and Vacation Bible School. (I can still recite the pledge to the Bible.) I attended “Lock-ins” where we spent the night in the church’s activities building and watched movies about the rapture and what would happen to people who were left behind. By the time I finished High School I had read the Bible cover to cover and most parts many, many times more than just the once. If you had cut me then, I would have bled some combination of Wednesday-night-supper iced tea, VBS red Kool-aid, and communion grape juice.
I got my degree from Baylor University – the buckle on the Bible belt. (I later worked there for 20 years.) You would have to look hard to find someone who has sung more verses of “Pass it on” than I have, maybe Kurt Kaiser himself, but it would be close.
And yet, and yet…my personal faith and the religion impressed upon me in this loving and wonderful upbringing have never aligned perfectly, sometimes not very well at all. For example, I can remember one particular discussion during the annual “Lottie Moon” drive for foreign missions offerings that makes the point. I asked my Jr. High Sunday School teacher why on earth God would make millions of Chinese people just so they would burn in Hell if they didn’t happen to be one of the lucky few who heard the Gospel from a missionary? I don’t remember my teacher’s response – but it was evidently not very convincing to me. (Middle schoolers can be SUPER annoying! I’m sure I was one of the worst.)
I was late getting baptized. Most of the other kids at church, even the late bloomers, were baptized by the time they were 10 or 11. But the whole language around getting baptized never made sense to me. People talked about a “Personal Relationship with Jesus Christ” – I didn’t know what that meant; still don’t really. People were ecstatic about being “saved” – my life was fine, what did I need to be “saved” from? I remember one older man in our church telling me, “The day you are saved will be the best day of your life! It will be more exciting than your birthday!” I kept waiting and waiting for something that exciting to happen to me – but it never did. Certainly not something more exciting than my BIRTHDAY, for goodness sakes!
By the time I was 13, and still not baptized despite being very involved in church, people started to notice. The preacher visited the house to check on me. Thank goodness my mom stuck up for me; she didn’t believe in pressuring people about religion even though she definitely wanted me to get baptized at some point.
I did eventually get baptized when I was 14 or so, much to everyone’s joy, except possibly my own. Looking back on it, I definitely did it because I felt pressured into it, not because I had experienced a significant conversion. I used to regret that I gave in to the pressure. It felt dishonest. Was it worse to lie about being saved or to not be saved at all? This worried me for a long time, but I eventually made peace with it. Just because I didn’t have a conversion experience doesn’t mean my faith isn’t real. I grew up in the loving lap of God. I was born there. From what did I need to be converted? I think of my baptism now as a ritual of growing up, a marker that I was old enough to be held accountable to God’s expectation for acting out of love for others and kindness instead of the selfishness of childhood.
I remember when I was a freshman at Baylor one of Billy Graham’s daughters came to speak to the incoming class. I remember her saying, “I know, I know, I know, I know, I know, I know, I know what I believe is true!” I remember receiving that with a mixture of suspicion and envy. Can she really be that absolutely confident? That seems impossible to me – is she lying? But, wouldn’t it be wonderful to be so absolutely certain about your faith? Now I am more comfortable with not knowing. I’m not nearly as envious of those for whom everything seems so clear.
My faith is important to me, central to who I am. It draws from the religion that I learned in church, but it is not that religion. As an adult I have clarified for myself that, much as I might like to, I cannot force myself to believe things I do not believe. For example, the virgin birth and the literal bodily resurrection of Jesus are not a part of my faith. I am humble enough to say, “Sure, I guess it might be possible – I don’t know everything that is possible or impossible in the universe.” But whether or not those things are literally true are not important to my faith.
The “Lordship of Jesus Christ” is not part of my faith. I don’t really even know what that means. I have read what the Bible says Jesus said, and I believe a whole lot of it. I believe we are all children of God. I believe there is a holy spirit. I believe in good, and that good wins. I believe that God is good. I believe if I need more details than that to live a virtuous life, that I will be given the grace to work them out at the time I need them.
I believe in prayer – even though I don’t really know what is happening when I pray. I don’t believe God is a big Santa Claus who gives you what you want if you ask for it fervently enough. I don’t believe if you have “enough faith” you can keep bad things from happening. I don’t believe that’s what God is – but that doesn’t mean I don’t believe in God. I do believe that God helps people when bad things happen to them. I believe that prayer is one way we connect to God in good times and in bad.
I often use the language of God and Jesus that I was raised with to talk about my faith, because that is the language I have. That doesn’t mean I think my tradition is the only or best tradition; it’s just my tradition. The language is largely symbolic to me, not literal. For me, that does not make it less true.
Do I believe that belief in Jesus is the only way to be “saved” – whatever that means? That is not part of my faith. Heaven and hell are symbolic, not literal, parts of my faith — at least until I find out differently someday.
Am I a virtuous person despite the fact that I don’t believe everything I was taught I am supposed to believe? I would like to think so. Some might disagree. Am I a Christian? I call myself a Christian. Some might disagree.
I have wonderful friends and family whose faith is very different from mine. That does not bother me. I am happy for them! I believe God is big and complicated enough that probably none of us sees the whole picture – and therefore we can be right and wrong about God in a lot of different ways. I have come to have faith that the faith I have is enough faith, and that if I need more faith at some point – I will receive it.
I can’t think of a time when I have shared all this publicly. My faith journey is important to me – probably the most important thing to me – but it’s personal. (Also, I don’t want people who love me, but who have very different faith from mine to worry about me.) It seems a little self-involved to think that other people would be that interested in my faith, and I am certainly not interested in “defending” my faith to people who “know, know, know, know, know” that what they believe is true. I don’t deny that is your experience, but it is simply not mine.
So why am I sharing it now?
I am listening to a book right now called, The Battle For the American Mind: Uprooting a Century of Miseducation by Pete Hegseth and David Goodwin, which according to the Harper Collins website is a #1 New York Times Bestseller. I disagree strongly with almost everything this book has to say, but it is a quirk of my personality that I feel obligated to hear what the “other side” has to say every now and then.
Without going into a lot of detail about the central thesis of the book, one of the things that the author brings up is the role of public school in raising virtuous children who go on to become virtuous citizens. I think I am representing the authors fairly to say that they believe this requires an education that has the Christian Faith as its foundation.
Though I disagree with the authors arguments and conclusions on this topic – I do think it is an important conversation. Is it the role of public school to raise up virtuous citizens? And if so, how do we go about doing that? Is it appropriate to “put God back in school” to accomplish this goal? Specifically, the Christian version of God? And if so, which “Christian” version of God? Mine?
The Constitution says, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…” but does that mean we cannot or should not practice the traditions of a particular religion in public school – Does that mean we should not pray together? That we should not celebrate Christmas at school? Does it mean that we cannot talk about religion and the role it has unquestionably played in history (for good or for ill)? Does it mean we cannot discuss the role religion unquestionably plays in developing morality and virtue (for good or for ill)? Religion, specifically the Christian religion, is a part of the culture of a majority of our citizens (at least for now) – is it the role of public schools to pass on the majority culture? That particular part of our majority culture?
My personal “testimony” (as I grew up calling it in the Baptist church) teaches me that faith is not easily pinned down in a syllabus, not easily marked correct or incorrect. My journey has taught me that I am not always going to believe what is commonly accepted as the “right” thing to believe. It has taught me that some people are fine with that, but that some people think less of me or worry about me if I am honest about my beliefs. I have learned that some people, sometimes with the best of intentions, can come across to me as “religious bullies” who have trouble resting until I say I agree with them about matters of religious doctrine.
My journey has taught me that, while listening to other people say prayers does not force me to believe what they are saying, refusing to participate in prayer time when everyone else is doing it can have unpleasant social repercussions. Should I just “go along to get along” if I am in the minority? Is it OK to put kids who are in the religious minority in that situation?
My journey leaves me believing that religion is a complicated topic, not one that lends itself productively to memes and bumper stickers and yelling at each other at school board meetings. I worry that for some people religion seems simpler, and that those people will not have patience for those of us for whom it is more complicated.
Does that mean that religion has no place in public school? I can imagine a skilled teacher leading a fair and fruitful conversation about religion that would help students draw out important lessons, but I can also imagine a passionate teacher, purposefully or accidentally, pressuring students to believe/not believe one thing or another. I am not sure the chance of good outweighs the chance of bad in that situation.
To me, saying “religion” has no place in public school is not the same as saying “God” has no place in public school. I bring my faith with me wherever I go. I hope that, most of the time, that means I also bring the kindness, grace and virtue that my faith inspires. I don’t believe we have the power to tell God where God will and won’t reside.
I think, to a fairly large extent, the public conversation about “putting God back in school” is really about putting specific religious practices back in school – for example morning prayers or singing religious Christmas songs.
We had morning prayers over the loudspeaker when I started high school, and we took them out somewhere along the way before I graduated. Honestly, I don’t think they made one bit of difference one way or the other. Maybe they were helpful to some. To me they reinforced the idea that religion was mostly a show. Even though, or maybe because, I was a devoted pray-er myself, I was glad to see them go. To my mind, first period was simply not the right setting for sincere, common prayer. I think we students benefitted more from our principal and teachers taking two minutes in their cars before they walked in the schoolhouse door to be still and say a little prayer before starting the day. I imagine many of them did that – just like I imagine there are many principals and teachers doing that today.
One of the religious images I remember from growing up, and still treasure to this day, is the image of Jesus standing at the door knocking. Knocking – not forcing his way in. This image reminds me that faith is something better invited in than forced in. If religion were to become a part of public school, whose religion would it be? Yours? Mine? How would we make sure those religious beliefs knocked at the door instead of using the weight of the expectations of parents, of teachers, of other students, to force their way in? For those of you who share the religious beliefs of the most vocal of those around you, that might not seem like a problem worth worrying about, or maybe even something to be desired. For those of us whose beliefs do not always match those of the most vocal among us, it is more complicated.